Greg H.
7/18/2025
This may be top tier ice cream destination in my opinion. They had so many choices and everything was divine. My wife had the Yankee-Doo which is two snickerdoodle cookies with vanilla custard...
Not Licked Yet Frozen Custard
$
Closed
(187)
Photos
4054 Main St
Fish Creek, WI 54212
Not Licked Yet Frozen Custard in Fish Creek, WI offers a delightful experience with outdoor dining overlooking the scenic shoreline and a giant playground for children. Guests can meander along Fish Creek, enjoying the Door County wildlife and landscape, or relax on heated patios and rocking chairs while savoring their famous custard delights.
Visitors can check the Flavor of the Day on their Facebook account and enjoy a serene evening stroll under twinkling lights and sparkling stars. With a reputation for world-famous custard and delicious food, Not Licked Yet is a must-visit destination in Door County.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
4.0187 reviews
Stephen D.
8/16/2025
Great custard! Glad they had my favorite flavor (cookie dough) as the special ice cream. Plenty of seating out back on a Sunday to not bump into a bunch of people.
Lauren G.
7/12/2025
We were here on a Friday night around 8:30pm. There was a long line to order ice cream but it went fairly quickly. I ordered the snowball inferno sundae which was pretty good. The custard itself...
Jaye S.
11/7/2024
Perfect end to a perfect day in Fish Creek! There were so many choices, both of frozen custard and sandwiches! I went with the simple tried and true vanilla custard....and it did not...
Hn W.
10/10/2025
Unfortunately, this isn't my first negative review on Door county restaurant service. Clearly all staffing goes through the same agency because these young workers are rude, eye rolling, no...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.