New York Deli

History

New York Deli is owned and operated by Don Sanderfoot and his son Carl Sanderfoot. During a visit to the east coast they were impressed by the numerous family delicatessens and sandwich shops operating there, especially those in New York. Fresh sliced, quality meats and cheeses piled high on great bread were the norm. Returning home, the disparity of a good sandwich became apparent, so they set out to recreate what they experienced in those delis. After five years, the menu has grown to include Deli Sandwiches, Subs, Wraps, Panini, Soups, and Salads. While constantly evolving, New York Deli continues to be the quintessential deli in northeast Wisconsin.

Specialties

The return of a classic, New York Deli delivers arguably the best sandwiches in the Fox Cities by drawing inspiration from the greats of the East Coast as well as from a long heritage of deli and restaurant owners. We pay hommage to the likes of Carnegie, Katz, and The Stage with our piled high Classic Deli Sandwiches and hot New York Style Subs while also offering new favorites like wraps, panini, and salads all featuring Boarshead Brand meats and cheeses. Customers can shop our market for gourmet meals, unique gifts, and more. Stop in and savor a slice of our house-made cheesecake with a Victor Allen signature coffee drink while taking in our latest local art installment. With an airy and spacious interior - furnished with contemporary flair, New York Deli is the casual yet refined spot to be in the heart of the Valley. New York Deli...more than a great sandwich