Mr G's Logan Creek Grille

$$
Closed
yelp logo

(39)

Photos

5890 State Highway 57
Sturgeon Bay, WI 54235
Restaurants have almost always been a part of the Geitner Family. Bob's parents, Bob and Lorraine owned the Nightingale Restaurant in Sturgeon Bay for over 20 years before purchasing Mr. G's in 1973, known then as Paldora Supper Club and the Fernwood Gardens Ballroom. His son, Bob Jr. Worked for his father for eight years before purchasing the restaurant from his parents in 1981 with his wife, Mary. Bob and Mary raised five children there. Matthew, Mark, Robert, Sarah, and Christopher have worked at the restaurant in some capacity over the years. They are proud to be celebrating over 40 years in business. Stop in and discover Mr. G's! Enjoy their old-fashioned idea of high-quality food, cozy atmosphere, friendly staff, and reasonable prices!

Reviews

yelp logo
4.039 reviews
Photo of Brian M.
Brian M.
10/12/2019

I recently saw Mr. G's advertised on a Travel Wisconsin page as one of those "must try" supper clubs scattered throughout our state. Seeing the ad coincided nicely with a planned Door County...

Photo of Justin B.
Justin B.
6/21/2021

We stayed in door County for a week and just so happen to pass this location. Let me start off by saying that supper clubs are a different monster than normal restaurants I believe this location...

Photo of Hillary T.
Hillary T.
7/6/2019

Mr G's is one of our favorite supper clubs in Door County! From their Friday night traditional fish fry to the cherry glazed pork chops the menu will not disappoint! When we come on a Friday night...

Photo of Gene T.
Gene T.
5/30/2019

We came back not for the amazing fish fry, but for something else. After a few minutes of serious contemplation, I decided on the1/2 rack of ribs. Something about winning the Door County rib fest...

Photo of Victoria K.
Victoria K.
6/16/2019

Cane here on Friday shortly after 5. Right after we got sat there started to be a wait. Service was still quick despite the business. I split an order of cheese curds and had the seafood combo...

Own this business?
See a problem?

You might also like

United StatesWisconsinSturgeon BayMr G's Logan Creek Grille

Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.