Mr Dye's Pies

$$
Closed
yelp logo

(40)

Photos

275 W Wisconsin Ave
Milwaukee, WI 53203

Mr. Dye's Pies is a renowned pie shop in Milwaukee, WI, known for their delectable pies and warm hospitality. While they are currently in the process of building their new home, customers can stay updated on their pie festivities through their active Facebook page.

For those craving a slice of heaven, Mr. Dye's Pies can be found at their premier location in the 3rd St. Market Hall on Wisconsin Ave. With a reputation for serving only the most delicious pies, this beloved establishment is a must-visit for pie enthusiasts in Milwaukee.

Generated from the website

Find related places

Reviews

yelp logo
4.540 reviews
Photo of Amy F.
Amy F.
7/1/2025

Pie connoisseurs must give this place a try...if you like thin, crispy pastry crusts, generous fillings, and fresh, warm pies when you walk up to the counter-this is the place for you! I came on...

Photo of Kat T.
Kat T.
9/1/2025

They offered samples and each pie was delicious. I left with a sweet potato pie slice and it was also delicious. This is a black owned pie company. The service was warm and welcoming and will...

Photo of Jill D.
Jill D.
7/5/2025

I order ALL of my holiday pies from ant Dye's Pies and EVERY time, its the highlight of the party! This time, I ordered A PEACH COBBLER -- outstandingly delicious. It was HUGE and I was worried...

Photo of Rick R.
Rick R.
2/3/2025

Recently, Mr. Dye's Pies launched housemade pasties! I tried the beef pasty, made with well-seasoned ground beef and potatoes, and the mushroom pasty, made with 3 types of mushrooms, celery, and...

Photo of Kushal D.
Kushal D.
7/3/2025

So so delicious! I came here for my husbands work event and they had a large selection of pies to choose from! We got the key lime and the purple pie - both were phenomenal. Crispy and delicious...

Own this business?
See a problem?

You might also like

United StatesWisconsinMilwaukeeMr Dye's Pies

Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.