John Paul S.
4/13/2011
Part of the Resort of the same name, nestled on the shore of Lake Puckaway, it is a good place to get away from the she-she pretensions of Green Lake This is one of the best family-style...
Mike & Cathy's Good Old Days
$$
Open
(11)
Photos
W995 W North Shore Dr
Montello, WI 53949
Mike and Cathy's Good Old Days provides an amazing, fine dining experience for all ages in Montello, WI on the North Shore of Lake Puckaway.
Also at this address
Reviews
3.511 reviews
Pete D.
7/2/2023
Worst server in my 57 years on earth. Wow, need your night ruined? Ask to sit on the indoor patio and feel the sour attitude. Would you like specials? "Well you are going to have to wait 45...
Sandy B.
2/1/2023
We typically go on Fridays for the chicken/fish. Awesome food, more than you could ask for and top quality! Wait staff are always polite and attentive!
S. B.
10/17/2019
Mike and Cathy know how to run a restaurant. Cathy is always pleasant and makes you feel welcome. The All You Can Eat Chicken and Fish is the best in the area. The waitress is attentive to you if...
Toshi K.
8/23/2017
DON'T drink the water! Food is mediocre at best. Cleanliness borders on health violations. Been there several times hoping things might get better.
Owner verified
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.