Art M.
9/22/2025
Great sandwiches! We had the beef panini with bacon and cheese and egg salad with arugula. Both with tasty and well presented. A side of bow tie pasta was a delicious! Service was fast and friendly.
McEvoy's Culinaria and Paella
$
Closed
(15)
Photos
2602 S Bay Shore Dr
Sister Bay, WI 54234
McEvoy's Culinaria in Sister Bay, WI, is a premier deli that emphasizes great food and exceptional service, offering a diverse selection of top-quality deli meats, cheeses, and salads, along with made-to-order sandwiches and packaged meals. Known as the "Paella People," they are dedicated to providing personalized catering for weddings and events while embracing the Door County lifestyle.
The deli features a variety of fresh, made-from-scratch options including daily specials, hot sliders, and family favorite packaged entrees, making it easy for customers to enjoy high-quality meals on the go. With a commitment to customer satisfaction, McEvoy's Culinaria encourages guests to explore their offerings and discover their passion for food and community.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
4.515 reviews
Alyssa M.
10/16/2023
We tried the chorizo and chicken Spanish paella at fall fest! All I can say is that it was so delicious!!
Gary M.
10/12/2023
Stopped for a sandwich for lunch...Good food...great service...would dine there again!
Divya R.
9/8/2023
Great paella right outside sister bay. Also a great outdoor seating area and great drinks. Only downside is that there are no vegetarian or vegan options.
Alan M.
8/14/2023
High quality deli that Carrie's Boar's Head meats and cheeses as well as terrific salads. Sundays, they cook paella out on the front the lawn and start serving at 5:00, truly a work of culinary...
See a problem?
