Dayna M.
9/14/2024
What happened to this place?! I've been to this location twice in the past year and both times were shockingly bad. Several months ago I placed a pick up order for lunch on a weekday. The place...
Jimmy John's
$
Closed
(32)
Photos
6921 University Ave
Middleton, WI 53562
We slice our all-natural meats and fresh veggies in-house every day. Our fresh-baked bread is made right here where you can see it, and our house-made tuna salad is fresh every day. The flavor of a ripe tomato, crisp shredded lettuce, combined with fresh-baked bread, fresh-sliced meat and real Hellmann's mayo - that's when the magic happens. Made with love every single day since 1983. That's Jimmy Fresh!
Also at this address
Reviews
2.032 reviews
Thomas T.
3/14/2025
Hard to complain, as I only needed a couple skinny/slim subs. It wasn't busy, so my sandwiches were done promptly. No complaints here, but nothing made this store stand out over others.
David H.
6/11/2024
Terrible. Showed up for Freaky Fast service after a 15min detour. I walked in to find the place completely dark with no power. All the other shops had power. I was told sorry they're closed due to...
Jon B.
10/29/2024
Close this location. Stale 2 day old bread, untrained staff. Sandwiches missing ingredients, slow r7de service. Never again Jimmy Johns.
Melanie N.
11/8/2024
I ordered lunch and accidentally transposed my suite number and I never received my food, was told I couldn't get a refund or a new order. So I'm out $32 and got nothing
Owner verified
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.