Tracy C.
9/30/2025
What a terrific place! It's like New York City in the middle of Madison. They have all of the fresh bagels, homemade cream cheeses and salads and sides. You can make it anyway you want it lettuce...
Gotham Bagels
$
Closed
(370)
Photos
112 E Mifflin St
Madison, WI 53703
Gotham Bagels, based in Madison, WI, is dedicated to serving authentic New York-style bagels to the Midwest. Established in 2006 by a native New Yorker, the company prides itself on using traditional ingredients that have been a staple in bagel-making for generations.
Each bagel at Gotham Bagels is meticulously hand-rolled, following a time-honored method that dates back to 1906. The menu features a variety of inventive sandwiches, expertly crafted with unique flavor combinations and fresh ingredients, setting them apart from the rest.
With a total of five locations, Gotham Bagels invites customers to experience the best bagels in the Midwest. Whether you're a bagel enthusiast or looking to cater an event, Gotham Bagels offers platters for every occasion, ensuring a delightful bagel experience every time.
Generated from the website content
Also at this address
Find related places
Reviews
3.5370 reviews
Jenni W.
5/12/2025
Having moved to Madison from Brooklyn, people have told me that the closest thing to a NY bagel was Gotham Bagels. After 2.5 years of living in Madison, I finally tried this place on a Tuesday...
Dana C.
8/8/2025
Fresh, tasty & delicious bagels. Many great options, love the lox & cream cheese. Super nice staff. Very cool vibe. Always takes longer than expected even when you order ahead so be prepared.
Pete J.
3/11/2025
Located just one block off from the state capitol square, I was able to find lots of street parking, at 10am on a Tuesday, right in front of the store. Walking in, the store is nicely decorated...
Felix S.
11/8/2025
Took over 2 hours to get 2 sandwhiches. Gave no realistic time line and seemed totally overwhelmed. Wasted a morning here.
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.