Dana C.
8/8/2025
Fresh, tasty & delicious bagels. Many great options, love the lox & cream cheese. Super nice staff. Very cool vibe. Always takes longer than expected even when you order ahead so be prepared.
Gotham Bagels
$
Closed
(367)
Photos
112 E Mifflin St
Madison, WI 53703
Gotham Bagels, based in Madison, WI, is dedicated to serving authentic New York-style bagels to the Midwest. Established in 2006 by a native New Yorker, the company prides itself on using traditional ingredients that have been a staple in bagel-making for generations.
Each bagel at Gotham Bagels is meticulously hand-rolled, following a time-honored method that dates back to 1906. The menu features a variety of inventive sandwiches, expertly crafted with unique flavor combinations and fresh ingredients, setting them apart from the rest.
With a total of five locations, Gotham Bagels invites customers to experience the best bagels in the Midwest. Whether you're a bagel enthusiast or looking to cater an event, Gotham Bagels offers platters for every occasion, ensuring a delightful bagel experience every time.
Generated from the website content
Also at this address
Find related places
Reviews
3.5367 reviews
Jenni W.
5/12/2025
Having moved to Madison from Brooklyn, people have told me that the closest thing to a NY bagel was Gotham Bagels. After 2.5 years of living in Madison, I finally tried this place on a Tuesday...
Pete J.
3/11/2025
Located just one block off from the state capitol square, I was able to find lots of street parking, at 10am on a Tuesday, right in front of the store. Walking in, the store is nicely decorated...
Chelsea C.
11/3/2024
Bagels were solid but the special sandwiches is where it's at! When I said I wanted my bagel NY style they delivered. Everyone we interacted with was super friendly and we will definitely be back!
Dave G.
10/20/2024
EDIT: I lowered their rating from 2 stars to one star. They made me wait 80 mins, were rude about it at the pick up window, AND they got the order completely wrong. IDIOTS!! The good: food is...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.