Cheryl B.
7/9/2025
We have been coming here, nearly weekly, since January 2025. It is situated in the town's old library, high ceilings and chandeliers. I have never once been disappointed. Nice crispy thin crust...
Goodfella's Pizza Pub
$
Closed
(39)
Photos
225 1st St
Nekoosa, WI 54457
Goodfella's Pizza Pub, located in Nekoosa, WI, is a beloved local eatery known for its made-from-scratch pizzas, pasta, and sandwiches. The establishment prides itself on its history and community roots, providing a welcoming atmosphere for both casual diners and those looking to host special events in its lower-level dining room.
In addition to a robust food menu, Goodfella's offers a selection of beverages, including beer, wine, and spirits, as well as specialty sodas. With a commitment to quality and flavor, it has become a popular spot for both locals and visitors alike.
Generated from the website
Reviews
4.039 reviews
Wendy W.
8/28/2024
We usually go to a different pizza place a little closer to us but wanted to give it a try. The waitress seemed a little off. Service was good not great. We had a meat lovers pizza it was good....
Dustin O.
9/9/2024
Food rating! 5 Stars for a unique pizza that has been true and consistent for perhaps 20+ years! Little fun fact, did you know it's run by a sitting Mayor? It's an old school library longtime...
Denise L.
7/7/2025
I cannot rate the food- never got the chance to order. We stopped on a Sunday evening, 6:00 pm , first time at this restaurant. The bartender/ waitress was rude, told us to sit wherever. The only...
Steve M.
9/14/2024
Stopped for dinner they were short handed waitress, bartender & kitchen help came and took our drink and food order within our first 10 minutes. . It was over an hour and I went to ask how much...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.