This shout out goes to Vickie H. in underwriting. She is the absolute best advocate for the Insured, Agents, and Germantown. She is super personable, and detail oriented. The world needs more...
Germantown Mutual Ins
Closed
(4)
W209N11845 Insurance Pl
Germantown, WI 53022
Germantown Mutual Insurance Company has been an important business in Wisconsin for more than 150 years. On April 1, 1854, the Germantown Farmers Mutual Insurance Company was established as one of the first mutual insurance companies in Wisconsin. The original officers and agents were prominent local leaders and dedicated to the development of the Germantown area. In the last few years the company has added several new lines of business, such as automobile, business owners and farm insurance. Through multiple mergers, it has acquired five other insurance companies that include City of Waukesha Mutual, Cedarburg Mutual, Lakeland Mutual, Menomonee Mutual and Retail Lumbermens Mutual. As a result of the acquisitions, Germantown has grown from a $5 million company in 1993 to nearly $37 million in written premium in 2005. Germantown Mutual Insurance Company is located in Germantown, Wis.
Reviews
Office J.
5/22/2025
Dakotah H.
5/13/2022
Don't ever go through this company! If you get in a hit and run/accident they'll do everything not to pay for damages! The insurance adjuster is 3rd party not even through them! They'll cancel...

Blake A.
7/22/2019
Seeing as the only review is from 2013, I'll add something new. This company has been more than helpful and has been very satisfactory in handling issues, including a recent incident with a car...
Brien E.
11/14/2013
One star is too good for this company. They are very eager to do business with you when they are collecting the premium. They are missing in action ( MIA ) when it comes to handling a legitimate...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.