Michael A.
10/15/2025
Great service and ice cream! Prices are a little high but it is worth it. Staff is helpful and friendly, great place to stop by for an ice cream.
Frostie Freeze
$
Open
(35)
Photos
208 Madison Ave
Fort Atkinson, WI 53538
Frosty Freeze in Fort Atkinson, WI is a beloved ice cream shop that offers a wide variety of frozen treats to satisfy any sweet tooth. With their online store open year-round, customers can still enjoy their delicious ice cream even when the shop is closed for the season.
From limited edition t-shirts to baby onesies and candles, Frosty Freeze also offers a range of merchandise for ice cream enthusiasts to show their love for this local favorite. Whether you're looking for a tasty treat or a fun souvenir, Frosty Freeze has something for everyone.
Generated from the website
Reviews
4.535 reviews
Amanda G.
9/27/2025
$$ Ok flash alert. They take cash or check. $$ So the ice cream was nice and smooth and velvety. I got a mango flavored cone. They did let me taste it before I purchased. That was good so I...
Heidi S.
6/22/2025
I heard about this ice cream shop on Madison Foodie, decided after seeing a show at The Fireside, my husband and I decided to try it! What a great ice cream shop and so delicious!!
Paul L.
5/31/2024
Just what we wanted for and ice cream stop! The banana split was large and in charge!!! The staff was friendly, quick and helpful with questions about the menu. The tables out front were clean...
Andrea P.
7/25/2025
Fun little spot with outdoor seats. Right on the road so a little busy but a safe spot to have a cone. They have frozen bananas!
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.