Jessica J.
10/2/2025
It's been awhile since I've been into Fitzy's but everytime I return I'm reminded of the great atmosphere and kind employees. In my head it's a coffee/ice cream shop. I almost forget the...
Fitzy’s
$$
Closed
(31)
Photos
424 E Silver Spring Dr
Milwaukee, WI 53217
Fitzy’s Cafe in Milwaukee, WI traces its origins back to 1954 when Fitzgerald Pharmacy first opened its doors with a soda fountain serving a variety of treats. Today, Fitzy’s carries on this tradition with a modern twist, offering a wide selection of items made with local ingredients and seasonal flavors.
From morning coffee to afternoon ice cream to lunchtime dishes, Fitzy’s caters to a diverse range of tastes and preferences. The cafe aims to provide a welcoming space where customers can enjoy delicious food and drinks in a cozy atmosphere.
Generated from the website content
Also at this address
Find related places
Reviews
4.531 reviews
Jose M.
7/27/2025
Wow! Fitzy's is a hidden gem in Whitefish Bay! a must for anyone looking for great sandwiches, salads and soups they are attached to a pharmacy and have some amazing and unique items for sale -...
Warren D.
6/16/2025
Date of visit: June 6, 2025 After a great dinner with a friend a few doors over at The Bay, we popped into Fitzy's so we could let them have the table and we could keep chatting about our recent...
Tasha B.
11/21/2025
It's a small little café inside of pharmacy had a little area where you can sit at the lady who was fixing our drinks was very sweet Best customer service drinks was great
Katie G.
7/17/2025
Had one of the best chais here! And the everything and schmear bagel was so delicious with a great side salad! This is a very cute spot in Whitefish Bay, definitely worth checking out.
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.