Jason G.
10/18/2025
Owner personality is great Pizza was great Staff is hard working We thought we would get one cheese pizza to go but ended up eating it there, drinking wine and beer and then ordered another...
Elmos Wood Fired Pizza
$
Closed
(13)
Photos
143 N 4th Ave
Sturgeon Bay, WI 54235
Elmo's Wood Fired Pizza, located in Sturgeon Bay, WI, prides itself on crafting pizzas with quality ingredients sourced locally. Their handmade dough and homemade sauce reflect a commitment to care and attention in every step of the pizza-making process.
Understanding that each customer has unique preferences, Elmo's offers a variety of customizable toppings and sauces. The establishment is dedicated to providing fast and friendly service, ensuring that every visit, whether for carryout or dine-in, is a pleasant experience for guests.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
4.013 reviews
Jill B.
11/1/2025
My husband and I were traveling back to Illinois from Door County and stopped by Elmo's for the first time to take a pizza with us on the drive home. What an awesome experience! it only took 10...
Deb L.
11/8/2025
Love a nice wood-fired pizza! Excellent quality on the ingredients. Nice chewy, well-fermented crust. Also can recommend the salads. Great addition to the local pizza landscape!
Chloe L.
7/18/2025
Everything was very tasty and the ambience and service were great as well! They're generous with their toppings. The pizza only comes in the one size pictured, but it was the perfect amount for...
Amy H.
4/12/2025
Amazing hand made wood fired pizzas! I've had the Elmo's special (pepperoni and hot honey) and a special the was wild mushrooms, goat cheese, and arugula pizzas, and both were fantastic. The pizza...
See a problem?
