Guadalupe G.
7/17/2025
Calamari was delicious as an app Loved their salmon pomo Fresca Server Henry was outstanding - truly! He was awesome and truly made the experience. Really knows the menu and offered OUTSTANDING...
Cafe Calamari
$$$
Closed
(259)
Photos
10 E Geneva St
Williams Bay, WI 53191
Family owned Italian restaurant overlooking Geneva Lake. Fantastic menu including seafood, pasta, nightly specials, and craft cocktails. Outdoor seating weather permitting. Minutes from downtown Lake Geneva. Reservations recommended. Private rooms available.
Reviews
3.5259 reviews
Frank R.
7/15/2025
Wonderful service from the host to our amazing server (Henry) we had an absolute amazing time! He has such great suggestions and offered honest opinions about which plates to select and how to...
Clara S.
8/5/2024
We were lucky to grab a cute table inside on this popping Saturday. Our service was great and quick. The complementary bread is a nice bonus too. I loved the menus with the pictures. My signature...
Justin A.
10/20/2025
Not worth the money. Arancini was cold, the calamari was rubber, and the pasta was well over cooked and lacked flavor.
Clare G.
7/17/2025
I am writing to share my family's recent disappointing experience while dining at your Williams Bay location on Friday, July 11th. After we ordered our main entrées, our server, Tanya H,...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.