Judy S.
10/27/2025
Stopped in for a quick bite while running around town. They have a cute area out back if you want to sit outside. We opted for bar seating. Hubs had a Guinness and I had a glass of wine. We noshed...
Bayside Tavern
$
Open
(220)
Photos
4160 Main St
Fish Creek, WI 54212
Established in 1930, Bayside Tavern is a restaurant and bar located in Fish Creek, Wis. The restaurant offers homestyle cooking and an informal dining experience, serving a variety of local seafood favorites, aged beef and wild game, an assortment of in-house baked desserts and breads. It is well-stocked with various types of beers, microbrews and wines, such as red, white, sparkling and blush wines. Bayside Tavern s menu includes a variety of salads such as canvas, caesar, chef s and lobster and asparagus salad, appetizers, potato skin, crawfish, grilled salmon, veal parmesan, sandwiches, rainbow trout, snowcap salmon, shrimp and scallops, sunset snapper, jumbo lump crabcake, pork tenderloin, lamb, veal marsala and ribeye. The restaurant also specializes in catering for corporate events, rehearsals dinners, weddings, anniversaries and birthday parties.
Also at this address
Reviews
3.5220 reviews
Justin M.
8/3/2025
We visited this restaurant about two years ago and had some of the best sweet potato fries we've ever tasted. Naturally, we had to stop by again on this trip. While we were there, the restaurant...
Suzie R.
6/24/2025
Had a lovely dinner at the very chill and old school Bayside Tavern. I sat at the bar and the staff were extremely attentive. I ordered the Door County Cherry Bomb, which has cherry flavored...
Sio B.
11/18/2025
First time here: 11/14/2025. Group of 5 for a late lunch (2pmish). Food = good Service = bad; unfriendly; not welcoming; seemed annoyed Ambiance = nice; local neighborhood pub We had the day's...
Jim K.
9/27/2025
Terrific hamburger plain with grilled onions, chips and onion rings. Cheese burger with tomato, lettuce second great choice.
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.