Bayside Bargains

$
Closed
yelp logo

(11)

Call
Website
14 S Madison Ave
Sturgeon Bay, WI 54235
+1 (920) 743-7048
http://bayside-bargains.hub.biz

Bayside Bargains is a consignment resale store located in Sturgeon Bay, WI - Door County. They offer a wide variety of used merchandise and specialize in providing affordable and unique items to their customers.

With a focus on consignment, Bayside Bargains provides a platform for individuals to sell their gently used items, allowing others to find great deals and treasures. Their inventory includes a range of products, from clothing and accessories to home decor and furniture. Bayside Bargains is a go-to destination for those looking for quality second-hand items in Sturgeon Bay.

Generated from the website

Also at this address

Reviews

yelp logo
3.511 reviews
Art K.
6/11/2025

This is a great consignment/resale shop; with a large selection of items, to explore and browse. We found an amazing ABP cut glass nappie, at a wonderfully low price (though we're aware this type...

Read more on Yelp
Amy J.
4/29/2025

The owner is unhelpful and extremely rude. I removed a price sticker from a pair of (over-priced) side tables that were buried under a bunch of dirty flooring materials and brought it to the...

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Jessica G.
Jessica G.
3/12/2023

One of the best thrift/consignment shops I've ever been to. Front showroom plus a huge warehouse. Lots of furniture and everything else. Great prices! Pickers dream.

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Steer M.
Steer M.
6/24/2022

Stopped in a couple of times recently. The first time was a great experience. Hands down. The second time the staff/owner with the ex-con haircut was unbelievably nasty and rude - completely...

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Evie B.
Evie B.
7/13/2022

Great store. Half price basement. Lots of goodies. Fun place to shop. Recommended. Furniture nick naks. Lots of stuff. Go visit

Read more on Yelp
Own this business?
See a problem?

You might also like

Antiques, Clothing and shoes, secondhand

Honeypicker

Honeypicker Consignment Gallery is a second-hand store located in Sturgeon Bay, Wisconsin, known for offering a large selection of quality items with reasonable prices. It is recognized locally for providing good customer service and serving as a reliable spot to find everyday goods. Regular customers frequently mention that they appreciate its conveniently small size and quaint atmosphere. Many prefer shopping here thanks to its fair pricing and consistently satisfying selection. This description was generated from their website
Thrifty Treasures
Antiques

Thrifty Treasures

1
"Absolutely loved this thrift store. The owners were so sweet and explained all of the deals. They had a ton of vintage and stylish items for affordable prices...we even got a shopping cart."
photo of Vanessa R.
Antiques, Clothing and shoes, secondhand

Mixed Basket

The Mixed Basket in Green Bay, WI has been serving as the city's premier consignment resource since 2005, offering a unique selection of home furnishings and d cor, including designer items from the Victor Merton home furnishings line. With a constantly changing inventory, The Mixed Basket provides a one-stop shop for those seeking quality home goods, art, furniture, and more, all at discounted prices based on how long items have been in the gallery.Generated from the website
United States›Wisconsin›Sturgeon Bay›Bayside Bargains

Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.

Partial Data by Foursquare.