Enjoyed a dinner stop here in the downtown location on a Sunday evening during an overnight stay in Wheeling in mid-June 2025. First, I would say this traditional spot is filled with history...

The staff was great the pizza was the worst I've ever had in my life worse than Domino's and that's hard to beat. Unbelievable I thought about bringing it back in the morning but I threw it out...

Grew up eating this pizza, stopped in recently while in town and glad to see it hasn't changed. If you've never had it before, hopefully you've picked up that the cheese goes on after it comes...

Finally got the chane to check out the legendary DiCarlo's! I really enjoyed the 3 slice combo, & the kids loved rhe pepperoni rolls. I am a fan of the Ohio Valley Style pizza that we get closer...

Great pizza. You really have to be a local to enjoy this pizza. We have had relatives from out of town, and served them this pizza. First they have never seen pizza served this way but after...