Dicarlo's Original Pizza

$
Closed
yelp logo

(21)

Photos

1724 Wheeling Ave
Glen Dale, WV 26038

History

Proud tradition, unique products & delicious pizza... The story DiCarlo's Pizza can be told based on these words, which has captured the heart of the family's philosophy for over 100 years. In the early 1900's Michael DiCarlo owned and operated an Italian grocery store in Steubenville, Ohio and later extended his endeavors into the bakery business. What today is known as Original DiCarlo's Famous bread, which is still sold in many areas of the Ohio Valley. Michael, who had immigrated from Sora, Italy along with his wife and six children ran all facets of the business enterprise. Returning home to Steubenville from serving in World War II, Michael's oldest son Primo described a dish that was popular in Italy. It was a delicacy consisting of crispy bread covered with sauce and cheese and it had been sold in many of the Italian cafes. His ingenious idea would eventually lead to the grand opening of the very first DiCarlo's Pizza shop located on 146 South 3rd street in Steubenville aroun

Specialties

Pizza Cheesy Bread Pepperoni Rolls

Reviews

yelp logo
3.021 reviews
Photo of Paul R.
Paul R.
11/24/2008

Since they moved a few storefronts up and added seating here (in a combined smoking/gambling room) there is nothing lacking from this location. Not quite as tasty as Elm Grove, but still...

T K.
7/30/2025

Why would you want cold cheese and cold pepperoni? Cheese is sour and crust was only half cooked.

Photo of Jason H.
Jason H.
7/25/2024

Not your typical pizza but really good. It's a must do whenever we are back in Glen Dale/Moundsville visiting family.

Photo of Chris H.
Chris H.
8/26/2024

Crispy crust with cold cheese and pepperoni, very good pizza. Descent price and friendly service.

Photo of Katrice K.
Katrice K.
5/17/2024

This was the best DiCarlos I've had since I've married into the Ohio Valley. The crust was crispy and not overdone, the dough was soft and delicious and the sauce was excellent. Not being from the...

Own this business?
See a problem?

You might also like

United StatesWest VirginiaGlen DaleDicarlo's Original Pizza

Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.

Partial Data by Foursquare.