Carl B.
8/8/2025
This place is wonderful! Low key, great food and service, a nice bar, indoor and patio seating, a medium walk from the Bainbridge ferry. It has become a regular dinner stop for me. AND, they are...
San Carlos Restaurant
$$
Closed
(148)
Photos
279 Madison Ave N
Bainbridge Island, WA 98110
Along with the delightful Southwestern menu, we are proud to serve the Best Margaritas in the West. Featuring among others: the Santa Fe (with fresh squeezed grapefruit juice) and the Skinny Margarita with Agave Nectar. We have twelve local and regio
Also at this address
Reviews
3.0148 reviews
Will L.
6/18/2025
San Carlos is a bit hit or miss. First, the hits: - It's open on a Tuesday, when many places on the island are closed. - Tons of indoor and outdoor seating, all comfy and welcoming. - The Tuesday...
Rich C.
3/2/2025
We had pre "Improv" dinner reservations; the restaurant being across the street from Bainbridge Performing Arts Center which deserves a 5 star review! Our table was in the bar as requested, we...
Lucy Y.
7/18/2025
Disappointing experience for a first timer at San Carlos. Food was excellent but disappointingly my partner was served a margarita in a lipstick-stained glass. When we flagged it to our server,...
Andee A.
7/10/2025
The margaritas and Smoked Chicken Carnitas were flavorful and satisfying. My Mom and I split the Key Lime Pie which was the highlight of the meal. Our waitress (with curly white hair) made the...
See a problem?
