Daryk O.
9/7/2025
This is my favorite pizza place hands down it's extremely affordable and delicious. The pizzas are simple the crust is good the toppings are plentiful and fresh. The staff is on point and the...
New York Vinny's Pizza
$
Closed
(162)
Photos
2132 SW 336th St
Federal Way, WA 98023
New York Vinny's Pizza in Federal Way, WA is a cozy pizzeria offering a taste of authentic New York-style pizza. With a menu featuring a variety of classic and specialty pizzas, patrons can indulge in flavorful slices made from fresh ingredients.
Whether dining in, ordering for pickup, or opting for delivery, customers can enjoy the convenience of savoring handcrafted pizzas at their leisure. The inviting atmosphere and friendly service at New York Vinny's Pizza make it a go-to spot for pizza enthusiasts in the Federal Way area.
Generated from the website content
Reviews
3.5162 reviews
Jessilyn C.
1/5/2025
Wanted to try some place different. Read reviews that seem promising. I'm really not a pizza person but of if I find something good, I'll make sure to order over an over especially hot supper...
Idi A.
6/13/2025
Went here looking to find good pizza in Federal Way, I'm still looking... they got my order wrong or short changed me on the double pepperoni on the menu... teenager behind the counter had zero...
John Barbara M.
1/14/2025
We had our second New York today. The pizza was delicious. This is the second time we ordered and this time there was nowhere near as many toppings. I think their product should be consistent.
Kim M.
4/14/2023
These pizzas are huge and very reasonably priced. Not quite as authentic or delicious as the New York pizza I grew up with in the Bronx, but OK for a place like Federal Way. Cheesy, foldable,...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.