Sarah P.
6/24/2025
I have always enjoyed the black raspberry flavor between the lemon cookies. When I first came to college in Lynchburg, Rookie's was the first place I went with my hall. There are good memories...
Rookie's
$
Closed
(80)
Photos
16145 Forest Rd
Forest, VA 24551
Rookie's started off as a vintage 1963 Kenskill Camper, renovated to serve handcrafted ice cream sandwiches, cookies and milk. Every cookie is baked fresh daily and the menu features new cookies each month. The mainstay ice cream sandwich (since Rookie's opened in March of 2017) is two "classic" chocolate chip cookies paired with vanilla ice cream - they call it the "OG".
Also at this address
Reviews
5.080 reviews
Jason G.
6/7/2024
Rookies was a college staple for me and I try to make my way back there every time I'm in town. I remember back when it was just a small operation, and so I'm impressed with just how much farther...
Be S.
4/12/2025
This place has been closed for months now. It was great while open. Just not enough business despite being in the mall.
Klarissa P.
12/22/2023
Absolutely delicious! My sister and her husband brought me here and the cookies and ice cream were great! I had the holiday flavors - snickerdoodle cookies with Christmas dough. Highly recommend...
Grace M.
12/1/2024
This place is amazing!!! The owners truly care about their craft. I love the ice cream sandwich - the chocolate cookie is a game changer. Would recommend coming early because they sell out! THE BEST!
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.