Wes A.
7/13/2024
After a bad meal at Blue 53s , I had to get the bad taste out of my mouth ! I stopped here for a soft serve peanut butter sauce with butter fingers milk shake! Way too much ! Very expensive but...
Papa Jim’s - Lake Monticello
Open
(3)
Photos
265 Turkeysag Trl Ste 112
Palmyra, VA 22963
Papa Jim's Ice Cream is a beloved ice cream shop with locations in Troy and Lake Monticello, Virginia, offering a variety of delicious frozen treats. Known for its specialty flavors and delightful banana splits, the shop invites visitors to indulge in a sweet experience during the warmer months.
The Lake Monticello location, formerly known as AMO Gelato Caffe, provides a cozy atmosphere for ice cream lovers to gather and enjoy tasty treats. With a commitment to quality and creativity, Papa Jim's continues to be a favorite destination for locals and visitors alike.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
2.53 reviews
Erin S.
5/23/2025
Ice cream was fine, but service needs work. I understand Friday nights get busy, but it doesn't take 30 minutes to make a plain milkshake that's ordered ahead of time particularly when it takes...
Kim H.
9/22/2024
I dont know what is happening at this location but twice we've received milkshakes that taste like watered down ice cream. I really loved the milkshakes at the Troy location and now that there's...
See a problem?
