Kristopher T.
10/9/2025
My family has really loved this place. We really like their new location. They always have a good selection available both for home and woman's clothing. I wish they had clothing for men, but...
On Second Thought Consignment
$
Open
(13)
Photos
201 Gristmill Dr
Forest, VA 24551
On Second Thought Consignment, located at 201 Gristmill Drive in Forest, VA, is Lynchburg's premier consignment shop, offering a vast selection of gently used women's clothing, accessories, home decor, and furniture in a welcoming 10,000 square-foot space. Since its establishment in 2004, it has garnered a loyal customer base and has been recognized multiple times as the Best Consignment Shop by Lynchburg Living Magazine.
Committed to quality and customer service, On Second Thought Consignment allows individuals to consign their items with a straightforward process, ensuring they receive 50% of the selling price once their items sell. Customers appreciate the friendly staff, diverse merchandise, and the consistent discovery of new treasures, making it a favorite shopping destination in the community.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
3.513 reviews
Joy F.
8/30/2024
This is a really nice consignment store. Obviously the prices are higher than at a thrift store, but most are not outrageous. My friend that was with me found two really nice pairs of winter boots...
Kim M.
10/30/2022
Great selection of designer shoes, accessories and purses. Didn't really find any clothes I liked in my size but they have a large selection. Their prices are not bad and the store was very...
Tiffanie C.
4/20/2023
I'm a regular consignment shopper and love being able find unique well-cared for items. This store did not let me down. It has an apparel and households location, in same shopping center. Both...
Dan M.
5/27/2022
Interesting dynamic at this business; somewhere between picky/rude and inconvenient. They are VERY discerning about they select and that's not such a bad thing but when you bring in high-end...
See a problem?
