Allison R.
7/15/2021
We got to enjoy the Ice Cream Cottage TWICE while we were in town last time! I tried a Better Brownie Batter shake Thai time which was good, but the brownie bites all just sank to the bottom and I...
Ice Cream Cottage
$
Closed
(13)
Photos
16430 Booker T Washington Hwy Ste 3
Moneta, VA 24121
The Ice Cream Cottage, located in historic Mastic, New York on Long Island, has been serving up super premium ice cream since 1990. With a charming interior that reflects both nostalgia and modern sensibilities, this award-winning ice cream shop has become a local favorite, known for its delicious flavors and friendly staff.
From classic favorites like Chocolate Overdose and Mint Chocolate Chip to seasonal specialties like Pumpkin and Red Velvet, the Ice Cream Cottage offers a wide variety of flavors to satisfy every ice cream lover's cravings. Whether you're a local regular or a first-time visitor, a trip to the Ice Cream Cottage promises a delightful experience and a taste of the Best Ice Cream on Long Island.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
4.013 reviewsHoward G.
5/22/2025
Ice cream was branded ice cream Not a high end product Had pricing like they were premium It was not Will not visit again
Lo S.
6/30/2024
I work here. The ice creams really good. Not bias. We work really hard and quickly. We get crowds through quickly
Kristen E.
8/20/2019
My family has never been so quiet as when they were devouring their Hershey's ice cream. Cones and cups are affordable in a wide variety of flavors with and without chocolate, coffee, or fruit....
Faith M.
6/28/2019
Drove out 30 minutes from the lake to grab ice cream after bbq Monday evening. Big mistake! The two young ladies working acted like we were bothering them when we walked in. Didn't want to help...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.