Andrew E.
7/2/2025
Their pizza is easily the best in Warrenton. Staff is always friendly for carryout too. Their cheesecake is also really thick and creamy New York style, delicious.
Goodfellas
$
Closed
(24)
Photos
251 W Lee Hwy
Warrenton, VA 20186
Good Fellas Pizza is a dining establishment located in Warrenton, VA, known for its variety of pizza offerings. While their website may occasionally experience technical issues, the restaurant aims to provide a satisfying meal experience for its customers.
With a focus on quality and flavor, Good Fellas Pizza is dedicated to serving delicious, freshly made pizzas. The establishment is part of the local culinary scene in Warrenton, attracting pizza lovers in the area.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
3.024 reviews
Sean K.
7/21/2025
I got a chicken parm sub with fries and an order of wings, mild with blue cheese. Nothing stellar about this place, kinda small but they have a couple tables for dine in. Food is average, the sub...
Erin J.
5/20/2025
I have been here a few times because it is close to work. The pizza is decent. However, the inside of the restaurant is icky! I saw an ant crawling on the table once time while I was waiting for...
Sarah D.
4/19/2025
Unless I'm insane I truly don't understand why this has any positive reviews. Only leaving two stars because it was affordable so I feel like I wasn't entirely scammed. Got a steak sub (at lunch...
Damian B.
2/9/2025
I ordered from them when they opened as Goodfellas pizza, the previous owners had it under a different name but still a pizza place. I enjoyed the pizza from the previous owners but Goodfellas...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.