Lloyd E.
10/6/2025
This IS my Go-To for Pizza, Stromboli and a good Greek Salad. The food IS always amazing and the service IS superb!
Elkton Goodfellas Pizzeria
$
Closed
(48)
Photos
100 S Stuart Ave
Elkton, VA 22827
Elkton Goodfellas Pizzeria, located in Elkton, VA, is a popular local eatery owned and operated by Michele Lucci, Raul Castillo, and Miguel Tellez. With a diverse menu that includes their signature Pizza Showcase featuring daily specials, customers can expect to be delighted by the creative and delicious offerings prepared by their talented chefs.
Under the management of Brenda Freykar, Elkton Goodfellas Pizzeria prides itself on providing a welcoming atmosphere and exceptional service to its patrons. Whether you're craving a classic pizza or eager to try something new from their ever-changing Pizza Showcase, this pizzeria is sure to satisfy your taste buds with their mouthwatering creations.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
4.048 reviewsJames M.
7/6/2025
Do you want the good, the bad and the ugly??? Good...pizza Bad...not much room Ugly...They're closed on Sundays or their phone no longer works
Audrine M.
7/2/2023
Highly recommend this restaurant for Italian fast food. Our waitress was amazing. She pretty much served all other tables but was very patient and helpful. We food is very tasty too. We ordered a...
Linda J.
5/17/2024
I have had takeout twice and finally have eaten in at Goodfellas! I was pleasantly surprised at such a great view of Elkton you have. Everything was bright and spotlessly clean. My server was...
Debra M.
5/31/2025
I loved this place before the pandemic. Quality has gone down but prices have gone sky high. The quality of their Parmigiano cheese is terrible. Sour at its best. How can you mess this up?....
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.