Bethany R.
7/27/2025
Everything was delicious! The pizza, the cheesy garlic bread, the chicken Alfredo and the calzone were all Devoured by our group of 5. Ordered a large pizza. Probably could have got away with a...
Pizza Mill
$
Closed
(181)
Photos
904 Mount Rushmore Rd
Custer, SD 57730
Pizza Mill is a cozy, wood-paneled restaurant located in Custer, SD, specializing in a variety of pizzas, hearty sandwiches, salads, and soups. The restaurant also offers a Take N' Bake option for medium and extra large pizzas, gluten-free items, and cheese bread, allowing customers to enjoy freshly made meals at their convenience.
While Pizza Mill strives to minimize cross-contamination, it is important to note that the restaurant is not gluten-free and cannot guarantee that food will be free from allergens. Gift cards are available for purchase, making them a great option for pizza lovers looking for a thoughtful gift.
Generated from the website
Reviews
4.5181 reviews
Catherine M.
8/19/2025
The pizza was ok...but the pick up process was definitely problamatic Unsure if it's related to staff issue or organizational issue. Had to wait 20 minutes after their order time per online...
Jenna H.
9/24/2025
Wow! Best calzone we've ever had. We sat outside on the patio during a beautiful late summer sunset and had an incredible meal. The staff was very helpful and friendly. The food was incredible....
L S.
5/31/2025
Nice to sit outside when weather permits. Order at the counter, get a number, then fill your own fountain drinks and enjoy a huge calzone or pizza. Sauce is on sweet side, fillings in canzone...
K B.
9/12/2025
Great calzone, we had the Towering Timber. The timber is loaded, and we ordered one calzone for two people. Plenty to eat and more to take home. Great service, great everything!
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.