Jordan W.
11/3/2025
Delicious food. The only flaw is the open kitchen leaves your clothes smelling like fried food, but otherwise everything else is 10/10. We opt for takeout usually!
New York by the Slice
$
Closed
(59)
Photos
921 W Carolina Ave
Hartsville, SC 29550
New York by The Slice is an Italian restaurant located in Hartsville, SC, offering a range of pizzas with various toppings and good-sized servings at reasonable prices. While patrons have noted the cleanliness and selection of the menu, some have encountered challenges with the friendliness of the staff and the stability of the toppings on the pizzas.
With a focus on delivering an authentic pizza experience, New York by The Slice aims to satisfy both locals and visitors alike. The establishment prides itself on providing hearty portions and a welcoming atmosphere for those seeking good Italian food in Hartsville.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
4.059 reviews
Kelly D.
10/7/2025
They don't know how to make pizza. When asked to leave in longer for the cheese to be a little brown they have no clue. They pull the pizza out to soon. Order a margarita one told them to leave in...
Crystal A.
7/13/2025
Great food, and service is always friendly! I definitely recommend this place when you're in town.
Frank W.
8/13/2025
Raw dough for the pizza. Veggies were not cooked. Mushrooms were raw. The service was good and the place was well kept.
Brenda U.
6/29/2025
My husband and I came in and ordered pasta. He ordered lasagna and after a 35 minute wait he got a plate with 5 pieces of lasagna in bite size pieces that was cold. I got fettuccine Alfredo 10...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.