Jenn M.
5/17/2021
I purchased the Apple Fry Pie at the Historic Round Barn. It is so good. I heated it in the microwave for 30 seconds and man was it delish! I will definitely buy more of these on my next trip.
Windy Hill Bake Shop
$
Closed
(10)
Photos
128 Field Crest Ln
Gordonville, PA 17529
Located in the quaint town of Gordonville, PA, Windy Hill Bake Shop stands out as a charming store that exudes warmth and comfort. Nestled amidst picturesque surroundings, this bakery invites visitors to indulge in a delightful array of freshly baked goods that are sure to tantalize the taste buds. From flaky pastries to decadent cakes, each item is crafted with care and precision, showcasing the dedication of the talented bakers behind the scenes.
Stepping inside Windy Hill Bake Shop, guests are greeted by the enticing aroma of freshly brewed coffee and oven-fresh treats. The cozy interior, adorned with rustic decor and inviting seating areas, provides the perfect setting to savor a leisurely morning pastry or enjoy a midday pick-me-up. Whether you're in the mood for a buttery croissant or a rich slice of pie, this charming store offers a delectable escape for those seeking a taste of homemade goodness in the heart of Amish country.
Generated using this place's available information
Reviews
4.510 reviews
Hannah H.
8/26/2016
Windy Hill Bake Shop is a small little to-go shack located in Gordonville. They are known famously for their fry pies, but they also sell cookies, homemade potato chips, and canned goods. They...
Fatty B.
8/17/2020
I bought two of these pies (peach, cherry cream) in the Reading Terminal Market on 8/15: The pastry (crust) itself was good and crispy with a decent taste, but the filling was bland and tasted...
H C.
10/10/2022
I had their mini Chocolate Whoopie pies and they were the best whoopie pies I've tasted!
Laura G.
8/23/2020
We buy the fry pies at the Shrewsbury market. We both enjoy them- my husband's favorite is the schnitz, and I am equally happy with either cherry or raspberry creme. Each time we get pies, they...
See a problem?
