Nikolas D.
9/2/2025
I'll be honest, when I first saw What If, I was skeptical. It's inside a Howard Johnson hotel, which I didn't expect. You walk down the stairs into a dimly lit dining room, with a crowded bar that...
What If...Of Hershey
$$
Closed
(257)
Photos
845 E Chocolate Ave
Hershey, PA 17033
Elevated casual dining experience, right past the buzz of downtown hershey. We offer Mediteranean and Innovative American foods. Parking is no issue with us and we have the best happy hour in town!
Also at this address
Reviews
4.0257 reviews
LCpl C.
10/22/2025
We reached out to What If in Hershey about catering our wedding (around 50 guests) at the Peter Allen House. The reply we received was curt and dismissive, offering no real explanation or...
Racquelle P.
2/15/2025
We tried this restaurant for Valentine's Day and we were not disappointed. We had reservations but still had to wait an additional 25 mins before we were seated. Once seated our waiter approached...
Julia R.
4/21/2025
Let me give you a recap of how What If is like... First, I come in and get a table. A waitress/waiter will come to the table quickly and introduces themselves. They will ask if you...
Andrew M.
4/5/2025
A hidden secret off the commercial side of Hershey. Great atmosphere, service and food!
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.