Allison B.
8/28/2025
There were 8 of us and we all loved our meals. The pork nachos were so good with all the different sauces. Our waitress was very attentive and kind. The restaurant was very clean with lots of...
Underdog BBQ
Permanently closed
(184)
Photos
3040 W Lake Rd
Erie, PA 16505
History
Underdog BBQ was founded by a group of Erie entrepreneurs who wanted to open a restaurant and create a sauce that represents the city of its origin. Like Erie, its local businesses, its people and the promise of its future...this dog is still in the fight.
Specialties
Smoked meats, delicious sides and the best local beers on tap.
Also at this address
Reviews
3.5184 reviews
Katie T.
7/15/2025
BBQ is just an all around "no". The pork wasn't "pulled" pork, it was chunked pork. Flavorless. The sauces are gross. Two guys at the bar were BLARING YouTube videos while we were there on Sunday...
Jeremy S.
8/25/2024
Underdog BBQ was, in a word, disappointing. We were visiting Erie for my birthday and had researched dog-friendly patios for dinner. Underdog does welcome pets, but that's one of few good things...
Kiarash A.
9/1/2024
We showed up on a Sunday for lunch. We were greeted and seated immediately. The service has been so friendly so far. We have ordered brisket and burnt ends along with hose salad and fried carrots...
Terry W.
9/13/2025
Been 2 years. This place went to the shits new menu items were awful. Brisket was fattiest thing I've ever been served. Turning in to a Mac & cheese restaurant. Bbq. What. Bbq
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.