Sheila S.
8/22/2025
We love Tomato Pie Cafe! 2 generations of our family have been going there for 30 years. Our favorites are the penne with pink leek sauce and the chicken Marsala and the grilled chicken salad with...
Tomato Pie Cafe
$
Closed
(75)
Photos
885 E Ingomar Rd
Allison Park, PA 15101
Tomato Pie Cafe has been owned and operated by Chef Rico Lorenzini for 24 years. Here we serve Italian American cuisine including Pizza, Pasta and Vegetarian Dishes. We use only locally sourced fresh ingredients, many of which are grown on site in our garden. We are also BYOB!
Also at this address
Reviews
4.075 reviews
Scott S.
8/1/2025
Easily the best pizza in Pittsburgh. Crust is delicious. The big name pizza joints in the area should take a lesson from these guys.
Jack D.
7/17/2025
I have been coming here since 2012 and it has always had the same freshness and quality of food through the years. Rico is the most incredible restaurant owner I've ever met. A great man through...
Carolyn K.
10/13/2024
The star of the show here (in my opinion) is the outdoor patio in North Park, the BYOB option, and of course the pizza. We got the pepperoni and was pleasantly surprised. They were severely...
Audrey W.
6/27/2025
Pizza was absolutely amazing, best around Pittsburgh. A bit expensive, but can be a nice treat once in a while. Heads up it's cash only, but they have an ATM inside
See a problem?
