Anthony O.
10/18/2025
Excellent! Throughly loved the Tomato Pie!! Service was great and ambiance was comfortable.
Tomato Pie Cafe
$$
Closed
(468)
Photos
23 N Broad St
Lititz, PA 17543
Many ask "WHAT IS TOMATO PIE?" Tomato Pie Café's Signature Dish is a Fisher Family Original. Deliciously seasoned red tomatoes are baked in a flaky pie crust, covered with a rich cheesy topping. Guaranteed to be like nothing you have ever experience before! Stop by, have a taste and experience a flavor so good we just had to name our Café after it. Deeply ingrained in our Café culture is the belief that food tastes better when you are with friends. Our customers are our friends, our honored guests! Please sit, eat, relax and let us give you a WAYLICIOUS experience you will want to sample again and again.
Also at this address
Reviews
4.0468 reviews
Kimberly T.
8/30/2025
whoa! thats one reaaally good tomato pie! ive never tried one before so this was a great treat! crust was so good and the tomatoes were fresh and bursting with flavor. So glad we tried their...
Marianne C.
6/6/2025
Very popular place in a very quaint area. We tried the storied tomato pie to share. Dear Lord! Lots and lots of cheese. It had the best non-home cooked pie crust I have ever had. I am a baker...
Sarah H.
7/2/2025
Great food and service- charming spot in downtown Lititz for food before 2! Great menu options- no matter what be sure to get a small namesake Tomato Pie - perfect for sharing even if you're...
Benny K.
8/21/2025
Charming diner located in an old house in the middle of Lititz. There's one parking lot well around the corner or just walk there if you're close enough. The tomato pie is a breakfast dish that's...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.