Anita H.
8/2/2025
Best ice cream around I cannot forget their waffle cones, which are also made on the premises (inside the creamery smells fantastic!) and so delicious! Eating beside the stream makes it even...
The Old Mill Creamery
Closed
(13)
Photos
6542 Buffalo Rd
Mifflinburg, PA 17844
The Old Mill Creamery is a charming establishment in Mifflinburg, PA that offers a variety of dairy products and sweet treats.
With a focus on quality and tradition, this quaint creamery provides a cozy atmosphere for customers to enjoy their handcrafted ice creams and other delights.
Generated from their business information
Reviews
4.513 reviews
Ashok J.
8/31/2025
We visited the old mill creamery to check out of they had anything unique. The price of a pint is almost close to two scoops, so got a pint of black raspberry after trying out some samples. The...
Laura P.
12/14/2024
Excellent ice cream and a good variety of flavors. They also sell milk, yogurt, cheese, and a few other snacks. Plus, they have a drive thru!
jessy s.
6/3/2025
Holy cow I love love love this place. In a beautiful rebuilt old mill is this whole milk fresh ice cream. I love every single flavor. I also love sitting out in the sunny weather by the seating at...
Christy H.
10/22/2025
First time here. They were out of mint Oreo, which ended up being a blessing in disguise because it forced me to step outside of the box and get a flavor I wouldn't normally get, salted caramel...
See a problem?
