McCall S.
7/6/2023
i literally LOVE this place. I always get it when I come visit my mom. I get takeout and although it takes about an hour/hour to a half, the food explains why. It's so delicious. This is the best...
Penn Street Pizza
Closed
(14)
Photos
500 W Penn St
Butler, PA 16001
Penn Street Pizza in Butler, PA is a beloved local eatery known for serving up delicious pizza, hoagies, strombolis, and other Italian favorites. With a focus on providing customers with quality food at a great value, Penn Street Pizza aims to deliver only the very best to its patrons.
Located at the corner of West Penn and Broad Street, Penn Street Pizza is a community favorite offering weekly specials like Pizza Night on Mondays and Hoagie Night on Wednesdays. Customers can also enjoy fundraising opportunities with the restaurant to support local schools and organizations.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
3.514 reviewsKiley C.
6/20/2025
We tried to order lunch on several different Fridays from my office. Despite everything saying they would be open at 11 am, they never answered. We called a day ahead of time (Thursday at 4 pm)...
Rick N.
8/28/2023
Wow is all I can say. The absolute worst thing I have ever put in my mouth. It tastes like a frozen pizza you get from sharp shopper and burned in your oven. Bought 3 pies and we all took 1 bite...
Erika V.
6/30/2022
Super hearty well-made pizza, and SO much tastier than the popular pizza chains...would absolutely recommend!
Karl D.
8/31/2017
Excellent people, pizza, and hoagies. Been here since 1980 and we order each time we come to Butler, PA. They could fix the sidewalk out front and their inside floor is a bit uneven, but it's not...
See a problem?
