Pagley's Pasta & More

$$
Open
yelp logo

(90)

Photos

1235 E Washington St
New Castle, PA 16101

Pagley's Pasta & More is a charming Italian restaurant located in New Castle, PA, known for its cozy atmosphere and generous portions. The menu features a variety of delicious dishes, including chicken tenders, cheese ravioli, and chicken Parmesan, all complemented by flavorful sauces that patrons enjoy with their fresh bread.

The establishment prides itself on its friendly and efficient staff, ensuring a welcoming dining experience for every guest. While the decor is simple, the focus remains on providing hearty, satisfying Italian cuisine that has made Pagley's a local favorite.

Generated from the website

Reviews

yelp logo
3.590 reviews
Photo of Jen P.
Jen P.
1/28/2024

The food here was awesome and I loved the pizza The chicken Parmesan was very good, loved how crispy the chicken was The 12 cut pizza with meatballs was delicious too. I actually bought their...

Photo of Dolly D.
Dolly D.
3/18/2025

Food was delicious. The service was horrible. We were told it would be a few minutes...no big deal. We were chatting to each other when a customer sitting at his table got our attention. The host...

Deniese G.
9/13/2025

The service was horrible not friendly at all. The hostess was extremely friendly and apologetic. They have no idea about gluten free and food allergies. My servers name was Mark and he never...

Photo of James F.
James F.
5/24/2025

Wow, talk about a difference since my last visit. Ordered the veal parmigiana with angel hair instead of penne, veal was tough and chewy, pasta wasn't angel hair- closer to vermicelli, pasta not...

Photo of Belle V.
Belle V.
1/15/2024

This is my second time coming to this restaurant. Very popular among the Italian community. One thing is for sure, you better come hungry. Their portion is big!! Service is good, staff are very...

Own this business?
See a problem?

You might also like

United StatesPennsylvaniaNew CastlePagley's Pasta & More

Partial Data by Foursquare.