Scott O.
10/12/2025
The cashier/server was very friendly. The food was hot and delicious! Pricing was reasonable. Definitely will be back to patronize this establishment in the future
Original Italian Pizza
$
Closed
(25)
Photos
32 Broadway St
Milton, PA 17847
Original Italian Pizza in Milton, PA is a local eatery specializing in traditional Italian cuisine. They offer a variety of pizza options along with other classic Italian dishes.
With a focus on quality ingredients and authentic flavors, Original Italian Pizza aims to provide a satisfying dining experience for customers in the area.
Generated from their business information
Reviews
3.025 reviewsBrad U.
6/24/2025
The food is very overpriced for what you get. The couple times we've ordered from here, the food was either bland or soaking wet with extra oil. Very friendly staff though everytime I've talked to...
Mary H.
9/21/2024
The service was quite good. The bread and house dressing were delicious. The entrees were smothered in way too much mozzarella; I just about choked. The sauce tasted like tomato sauce with no...
Mel B.
11/4/2021
Amazing. Let me tell you why. First off I've lived in Italy, two years. The owner being from Italy makes the food that much better. True Italian food! It's fresh, made to order and comes out...
Jenny M.
7/16/2022
Called in a pizza for pickup as a backup plan. We ordered a "supreme" which they said was the OIP classic and listed off all the ingredients to see if that's what we wanted. Went to pick-up the...
See a problem?
