Old Thyme Pizza and Subs

Closed
yelp logo

(3)

Call

Photos

12756 Dunnings Hwy
Claysburg, PA 16625
+1 (814) 239-2800

Also at this address

Reviews

yelp logo
4.53 reviews
Photo of Craig J.
Craig J.
8/15/2025

At their new location just south on the same street with the new owners, it was great! They have a new crust that is perfect with the thin and crispy NY or Boston style pizzas. Great deal on...

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Mike T.
Mike T.
1/8/2018

Pretty Decent little Pizza Shop in Claysburg,PA. Old Thyme offers a really extensive menu offering Pizza,Subs,Wings,Italian Dishes and a lot more. The prices are great for the area and they appear...

Read more on Yelp
Photo of James N.
James N.
6/7/2018

Wonderful food, the Stromboli are very large and the sauce is served on the side which suits our taste perfectly! Try one of the hot subs ... all are very good!!!

Read more on Yelp
Own this business?
See a problem?

You might also like

Allstar Pizza & Subs

1
"The pizza is the best in town, although I was not real impressed with the subs I've had there. The salads are very good, and the italian dressing is the best! The pasta is very good as well...."
Mamma Mia's
Eating places, Italian restaurant

Mamma Mia's

14
•
$$
"Friendly service, delicious bread and loved my Philly chicken cheese steak. Highly recommended."
photo of Doug O.
All Star Pizza & Subs

All Star Pizza & Subs

6
•
$$
"We decided to try somewhere new because we have a habit of driving 45 minutes or more just to try somewhere haha. That being said the first thing I noticed when I opened the box of pizza was the..."
photo of Alesia B.
United States›Pennsylvania›Claysburg›Old Thyme Pizza and Subs