Old Mill Pizzeria

$
Open
yelp logo

(27)

Photos

5784 Route 209
Sciota, PA 18354
Old Mill Pizzeria provides pizza, subs, and Italian pasta dishes to the Sciota, PA area.
Call Today

Reviews

yelp logo
4.027 reviews
Photo of John L.
John L.
5/26/2020

Located a stones throw away from a beer store so it was a convenient find for grub. The staff seemed like they were related and were very friendly. Unfortunately with the pandemic, the seating...

Photo of Dan M.
Dan M.
2/22/2024

I only like there pizza and cheesesteak sandwiches Don't care for there pasta dishes

Photo of Randy P.
Randy P.
12/2/2023

Food 4 . Price 1. Ridiculous $34 for 2 cheesesteaks and 2 fry's. FJB. 85 characters shouldn't be required.

Photo of Vicki M.
Vicki M.
8/2/2023

First (and last) time. Small meat pizza, doughy, mediocre at best. Wings were inedible. Tasted dry like they'd been deep fried before and refried as our order was placed. The small Greek salad...

John M.
4/18/2021

Veggie pizza with ham was fantastic. Service was quick and the staff was friendly. They even helped with next morning breakfast recommendations.

Owner verified
See a problem?

You might also like

United StatesPennsylvaniaSciotaOld Mill Pizzeria

Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.

Yext