Nikki's Custard

$
Open
yelp logo

(19)

Photos

1832 Oregon Pike
Lancaster, PA 17601
Nikki's Custard ~ Lancaster, PA.... Discover Nikki's Custard, a woman-owned, family-run frozen custard shop inspired by classic Midwest "mom and pop" stores. Our focus is on high-quality, fresh flavors made daily, including non-dairy and gluten-free soft-serve.

Reviews

yelp logo
4.519 reviews
Photo of Austyn S.
Austyn S.
6/17/2025

I did not do my research and I did not know that it was card only. I already ordered my food of the raspberry Oreo custard, and then I was holding my cash and the lady said that they were card...

Photo of Jackie A.
Jackie A.
6/16/2025

Honestly, I felt happy when I walked into Nikki's Custard. The employees cheerfully greeted me and asked how they could help. First time in, trying to get the lay of the land. I didn't realize...

Photo of Akash J.
Akash J.
6/18/2024

Saw a line going around the building and figured I had to give it a shot. Funny thing is, I thought the custard was just ok--a place that only offers three flavors of custard needs to knock it our...

Photo of Kenneth N.
Kenneth N.
6/20/2024

Is you want unique flavored soft served ice cream, Nikki's Custard is the place to go. I was in search for a banana soft served and they happen to have it this week. I'm dieting but whatever. I...

Photo of Thomas M.
Thomas M.
3/25/2025

Really good custard, reminiscent of Culver's. I've had chocolate peanut butter most recently and it was really good. My wife enjoys the dairy free offerings. Flavors are switched up often. Not...

Own this business?
See a problem?

You might also like

United StatesPennsylvaniaLancasterNikki's Custard

Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.

Partial Data by Foursquare.