Karen P.
9/15/2025
Muscarellas was a complete surprise for me. From the outside you get the impression you are just entering a small humble local bar, but once inside everything changes. The space opens up to...
Muscarella's Cafe Italia
$$
Closed
(208)
Photos
500 W Main St
Sharpsville, PA 16150
Muscarella's Cafe Italia is a renowned Italian restaurant located in the heart of the Shenango Valley, Mercer County. With over 25 years of experience, they have been serving authentic Italian family recipes prepared by skilled chefs using the freshest ingredients, offering a wide range of dishes that have won numerous awards.
From fine dining to bar food and elegant banquet dishes, Muscarella's is committed to raising the culinary standard in the area, providing delicious food in an inviting atmosphere at affordable prices.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
4.0208 reviews
Samantha H.
9/25/2025
Came late an hour before closing and we were still so kindly accommodated. The restaurant was themed for Xmas in July? Very cute. Lots of space for big parties but also smaller tables and booths...
Bill D.
9/8/2025
Fun place Huge portions Happy servers. Chicken carbonara very good. Very rich. Lasagne was great and a C lot if it. Highly recommend.
Jennifer C.
11/3/2025
Stopped in for lunch, food was good, service was good, nice environment. The desert not so good. I would stop in again and try other things. Probably will skip desert though.
Kiera B.
2/13/2025
Myyyyyy goodness gracious. Got the "Manzo" off the specials menu & I am so glad I did! What an absolute blast of flavors that all paired so well. Chargrilled 16oz. New York Strip, Cheese...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.