Mrs Gibbles's Restaurant & Candies

$$
Closed
yelp logo

(22)

Photos

7325 Molly Pitcher Hwy
Greencastle, PA 17225
At Mrs. Gibble's Restaurant we serve traditional Pennsylvania comfort foods and we are all about the family! What better time to enjoy each other's company than when you are sitting around the table sharing a meal! All of our foods are family recipes and are made in house. None of our entrees come pre-packaged. We are known for our Grilled Pork Tenderloin which we season with our secret family recipe! Other top entrees are Delmonico Steak, Fried Chicken, Homemade Hamloaf, BBQ Ribs, and our own Smoked Beef Brisket. We roast our own Turkey which is a special available on Tuesdays, Thursdays, Saturdays and Sundays. We are also known for our famous homemade Corn Fritters which are endless and make the meal complete. They are so deliciious! Also, when you come to Mrs. Gibble's, you can visit our Candy Store which is located right beside our restaurant. We hand-dip all of our chocolates and the center recipes are all original family recipes. The recipes for our cream centers are especially unique in that they are very smooth and not gritty like most creams. Mrs. Gibble's is owned and operated by the Eshleman Family and is named after Vernice Eshleman's mom, the late Mary Gibble.

Reviews

yelp logo
3.522 reviews
Photo of Shawn H.
Shawn H.
4/25/2010

I'm a fan because this is the best food you can get at any restaurant in the area. The fried chicken is fabulous and the pork tenderloin is done just right every time. I also like that the sides...

Renee B.
7/20/2025

I have been away from MD/PA for six years. Before 2020 I ate at this restaurant at least four times a year. The food and service were always good. I get that a lot of businesses suffered during...

Photo of Angela S.
Angela S.
1/1/2022

Visiting from out of town and came here for dinner. First order of corn fritters was ok only because they were cold. Second serving was better because they came out hot. Tasted like a beignet. For...

Photo of Scotty M.
Scotty M.
10/22/2023

Here's what I experienced. We arrived at 4:15p and were seated/greeted promptly and cordially. The dated interior was clean especially the bathrooms. The young waitress was very accommodating. I...

Photo of Gunter K.
Gunter K.
7/27/2019

It's a little bit of a drive, but if you want the best pork chops ever it's absolutely worth it. It's reasonably priced, simple and excellent cuisine. And yes, on the way out we visited the candy...

Own this business?
See a problem?

You might also like

United StatesPennsylvaniaGreencastleMrs Gibbles's Restaurant & Candies