M&P Coney Island

$
Closed
yelp logo

(27)

Call
Website

Photos

2712 Wilmington Rd
New Castle, PA 16105
+1 (724) 654-4522
http://www.mpconeyisland.com

MP Coney Island has been a beloved establishment in New Castle, PA since 1923, known for serving some of the nation's best chili and hot dogs. Their famous chili sauce is available for purchase online and in select stores across western Pennsylvania, Ohio, and Buffalo, New York.

Founded by Greek immigrants John Mitsos and George Papazekos, MP Coney Island prides itself on offering a clean and welcoming environment for customers to enjoy their delicious menu offerings. With a reputation for friendly staff and generous portions, this family-owned restaurant continues to be a local favorite for those seeking a taste of classic American comfort food.

Generated from the website

Reviews

yelp logo
3.027 reviews
Bret M.
10/15/2025

What an awesome experience! After having a nightmare experience at Soni's Italian. Never been here before but what a treat! Good food affordable prices and good service no wonder it's been open...

Read more on Yelp
Bill M.
11/24/2024

While tasty the hot dogs are quite small and the average adult will need 2 for a meal. The chili dog had the right amount of chili and the Chicago dog was good, even if there were more toppings...

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Heather T.
Heather T.
5/14/2024

This place is a little gem ! Almost everytime we come down here we stop here for the fries and the hot dogs! Amazing service everytime

Read more on Yelp
Dave F.
3/7/2024

Cold food no sport pepper hot dogs and chili barely warm. Pretty bad. Bad. Bad. Poor bad ack

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Maya K.
Maya K.
9/15/2022

Been going here for literal decades, one of my mainstays for local dining. Quality never changes. The vibes have changed a little over the years but that's okay. They didn't take cards until,...

Read more on Yelp
Own this business?
See a problem?

You might also like

Land of Make Believe
Gift shop, American restaurant

Land of Make Believe

Land of Make Believe is a whimsical destination in Hudson, OH that offers a variety of interactive experiences for visitors of all ages. From imaginative play areas to creative workshops, this unique establishment fosters a sense of wonder and creativity in a charming setting. Generated from their business information
El Canelo
Eating places, Mexican restaurant

El Canelo

47
•
$
"There are two Mexican spots to eat in New Castle PA. El Canelo on Wilmington rd., and the place on 224 going to Poland OH. i've eaten at both several times each. El Canelo is just better. the..."
photo of Rick L.
Chuck Tanner's Restaurant
Eating places, Italian restaurant, Caterers

Chuck Tanner's Restaurant

33
•
$$
"We eat at Chuck Tanner's often and have done so for many years. We love the breakfast that they serve. My favorite meal is the stuffed breast of chicken that they serve on Sundays. The waitresses..."
photo of Joan A.
United States›Pennsylvania›New Castle›M&P Coney Island

Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.

Partial Data by Foursquare.