Milroy OIP - Original Italian Pizza

A gem in Milroy. My wife and I stayed in the area for a night and were interested in getting Italian. My wife ordered the grilled chicken salad and I ordered the special Stromboli. Her salad...

It was AMAZING! The food was amazing, but just make sure your teen is fine with having a tiny bit of food if they order from the kids menu. The service was great, but there was just one waiter...

Very Nice people. Great food. The eggplant parm sub I had was excellent. Next time I'll have a calzone.

Nice quaint little pizza shop. A nice young Amish couple tied their horse and buggy to a tree and went in just ahead of us!

I didn't go to 5 just because of the high expectations I have for OIP places. This is up there....really it is. There's 2 in our area I prefer over this one (Burnham and Downtown). Excellent...