Mary E.
3/1/2025
For all the years I have lived in York, HOW have I never been to Mexitaly before?? I guess I was worried it would be an incongruous mixture of the two cuisines- but that is far from the...
Mexitaly
Permanently closed
(278)
Photos
2440 E Market St
York, PA 17402
Mexitaly Is A Scratch Kitchen And Brewery. We Pride Ourselves In Providing Good Quality And Quantity At Fair Prices. Stop In For A Pint! COVID hours are now 11-9 everyday.
Also at this address
Reviews
4.0278 reviews
Craig D.
7/28/2025
I used to be a regular customer at Mexitialy, since the beginning. The food is not the problem, it's always great! But, now it has gotten so expensive to eat there I rarely go anymore. I haven't...
Liz M.
12/15/2024
I had my doubts that a Mexican Italian restaurant could be good and my doubts were correct. It is very tex mex and you're typical Italian American food. The actual flavor of food is pretty mid....
Robert C.
5/19/2025
Food was so so, abundant but not particularly tasty. I left a tip of $10.34, but my credit card questioned it because they charged a tip of $20.00 [43% of the bill]. I was ripped off. Do not trust...
Tr K.
4/14/2025
showed up for a jam session, great home brewed beers, hung with the owner Greg and played some tunes. great chill vibe, highly recommend.
See a problem?
