I was in Erie a week ago and I always make it a requirement that I have at least one meal at the Oakwood - primarily for the lake perch. I invited my sister and all of her kids and grandkids and...
McGarrey's Oakwood Cafe
$
Open
(77)
Photos
1624 W 38th St
Erie, PA 16508
McGarrey's Oakwood Cafe has been a staple in Erie, PA since 1978. Our family owned restaurant is best known for our Reuben Sandwich. We pride ourselves on excellent service with great food and affordable prices!
Reviews
Mike S.
10/21/2025
Marcus L.
10/18/2025
The interior isn't very cute but the reuben sandwich makes up for it tenfold. Despite its somewhat soggy bread, the reuben is incredibly tasty and pack fulled of meat and sauerkraut. Additionally,...
Sonia L.
8/25/2025
Seat yourself, but it is busy in here. We grabbed the only empty table, 5:30pm on a Monday. Not much space between tables. The food came out fresh and fast, which we love. Daughter says "great...
Tammy S.
8/29/2025
Excellent home cooked food and great service. Would def go back if I lived in Erie. Baked haddock was outstanding.
Edward K.
4/9/2024
Overall, it was a great experience. . Pros- Service was friendly, knowledgeable, helpful, and pleasant. 100% happy with our server. Awesome menu variety. Very nice food portions. Loved the...
Owner verified
See a problem?







