Making Sense

$$
Closed
yelp logo

(13)

Call
Website

Photos

110 Old York Rd
New Cumberland, PA 17070
+1 (717) 763-7367
https://www.makingsenseconsignment.com

Specialties

We invite you to come visit our store. We carry a large ever changing inventory of clothing and home furnishings & accessories. Our clothing line includes the top designer name brands for women, men & children. We are very proud of the top quality, carefully selected clothing, accessories, handbags, and jewelry that you will find here...not to mention that we carry all sizes. Our home furnishings include: Accent Pieces Artwork Mirrors Lamps End & Coffee Tables Couches Bedroom Furniture Glassware China Sets Antique & New Furniture...you just never know what you will find...all at prices that can't be beat! And for those of you that have things to sell...please call us to set up an appointment to bring your items in. We look forward to meeting you.

Also at this address

Reviews

yelp logo
3.513 reviews
Photo of John G.
John G.
12/3/2019

They are "NOT" Open on Mondays. They are in the midst of a 50% "moving" Sale going on as of 12/2/2019 They are moving to: Fairview Commons 110 Old York Rd. New Cumberland, PA 17070 call their #...

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Susan K.
Susan K.
12/2/2021

I have consigned a few things. I like what she Carrie's in the store. I always see things I like. Consigning is a bit frustrating because she has limited times she takes consignments and I have...

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Stanley B.
Stanley B.
7/14/2020

Tried to use their store twice now. I do understand the Covid crisis and dropped off items to sell but the store was closed the entire time my items were there. I assumed they would work with me...

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Carol B.
Carol B.
7/7/2016

Very lovely owner. Lots of things from clothes, furniture ,housewares, bowls, China. I found a great handmade wicker picnic basket and a artisan pottery bowl Dog friendly They have dates that they...

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Naomi S.
Naomi S.
10/23/2020

Very disappointed that not one employee wore a mask. Such a small thing to do to protect their customers. I guess that tiny bit of defiance is worth more than other people's safety.

Read more on Yelp
Own this business?
See a problem?

You might also like

Divine Consign
Inspection and testing services, Clothing and shoes, secondhand

Divine Consign

3
•
$$
"great little consignment shop on the square in manheim with women's clothing (size 0 - plus sizes); junior's clothing, kids clothing, some new candles, used books, shoes, purses, and home..."
photo of Ashley Z.
Just Theresa's
Inspection and testing services, Antiques, Clothing and shoes, secondhand

Just Theresa's

8
"Always a treasure hunt when I come here. Never know what I will find. Theresa is nice to chat with."
photo of brandi C.
Red Door Consignment Gallery
Antiques, Inspection and testing services, Home furnishings, secondhand

Red Door Consignment Gallery

23
•
$$
"Are you in the market for affordable dining room furniture? Red Door Consignment should be your go-to for pre-loved quality furniture. Today, I spotted a beautiful mahogany table with table pads,..."
photo of Eugenia H.
United States›Pennsylvania›New Cumberland›Making Sense

Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.

Partial Data by Foursquare.