Zack G.
9/28/2025
Mennonite ice cream shop (+ small market) with delicious homemade ice cream + waffle cones Have a bunch of unique ice cream creations such as "fried ice cream" Tons of seating both in and outside
Lapp Valley Creamery & Cafe
Closed
(24)
Photos
4040 Old Philadelphia Pike
Gordonville, PA 17529
We offer a variety of fresh hand-dipped ice cream and milk products straight from our own farm and Jersey cows! We offer over 17 flavors of ice cream, specialty sundaes and ice cream creations, creamy milk products, chocolate milk, espresso drinks, and much more! Stop by our cafe and ice cream shop and taste the difference that fresh milk, ice cream, and food products can make with some of the best-tasting dairy products and food available in Lancaster County.
Also at this address
Reviews
4.524 reviews
Trish K.
10/6/2025
This place rocks! Cool indoor little play place for the kids. Lots of seating and parking. Generous scoops! The food looks good but we just got the ice cream. You can buy frozen food to take with...
Saira K.
5/8/2025
Amazing place! You have to stop here! Their ice cream is amazing! So rich and creamy! The strawberry flavor, the fresh smell, I don't think I've enjoyed strawberry ice cream this much before!...
Ashley C.
9/3/2025
The first time I visited Lancaster (last year), I got two Lapp Valley cookies and cream ice creams (double scoops). This time, I got 3! That's how good this place is. It's truly the best ice cream...
Clemence C.
7/8/2025
The ice cream at this place is awesome and so creamy! I got the coconut ice cream with fudge! A delight! They have an indoor playground and a store with some local specialties. They also sell...
Owner verified
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.