Diane H.
9/25/2025
The sweets at this bakery are to die for!!!! I thought I died and went to heaven with the chocolate raspberry cupcake . Also had the smores one! There is a little table to buy discounted treats...
Just Like Magic Bakery
Open
(6)
Photos
Stroudsburg, PA 18360
Just Like Magic Bakery is a whimsical destination located in the heart of the Pocono Mountains, offering a unique blend of enchanting confections and delightful treats. Known for its custom cakes and dessert bars for weddings and special events, the bakery invites customers into a collaborative process that transforms every order into a magical masterpiece.
More than just a bake shop, Just Like Magic Bakery serves as a community landmark where imagination and creativity come together to create sweet delights. With a dedicated team of bakers and confectionery enthusiasts, the bakery aims to sprinkle joy into every bite, ensuring that each visit is a sensory journey filled with charm and wonder.
Generated from the website
Reviews
3.56 reviews
Tina T.
11/9/2024
We popped in while walking on Main Street. We bought 3 cupcakes, red velvet, vanilla, and chocolate lava. The actual cake part was dry but I loved that the chocolate cake actually had a lava...
Margaret I.
9/20/2025
This bakery is absolutely amazing! The staff was so kind and helpful. I have never been a fan of buttercream icing, and this is absolutely my favorite. It has the perfect amount of sweetness and...
Ginny R.
9/20/2025
Terrible baked goods. They cinnamon buns were tasteless an the cream cheese frosting had no sugar or flavoring.the display cases were lacking product and the decor was extremely tacky. The product...
William P.
3/3/2024
After my third trip to the bakery, I'm said to say the magic hasn't been there. Although a clean establishment, it is bland, and the baker sacrifices flavor for tons of sugar. But the worst...
See a problem?
