Elena O.
12/16/2023
Love this place! We've found so many incredible pieces here. And the staff is so friendly! Great prices, too!
It's New To Me
$$$$
Closed
(13)
Photos
522 Valley Brook Rd
Venetia, PA 15367
It's New To Me is a consignment store located in Venetia, PA, and has been under the ownership of Elaine Fitzgerald since 2004. With over 4,000 consignors, the 6,000 square foot space showcases a diverse collection of upscale furniture, fine art, classic china patterns, and everyday items, catering to a broad range of tastes and needs.
The store embraces a unique philosophy that encourages customers to part with items their decorators recommend letting go after five years. This approach has established It's New To Me as a go-to destination for interior decorators seeking beautiful pieces that reflect impeccable taste.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
3.013 reviews
Margo A.
5/11/2025
It's New To Me is... an experience. If you're in a time crunch, this is not the place to stop and shop. The store has thousands of pieces, and it is quite cluttered so you'll have to move through...
Stacy C.
3/9/2025
I gave them about 20 items to sell for me. I have only received paymenton two. When I went through the store to see if my items were still there, hardly any were there which means they were sold....
Carol R.
4/21/2021
I was in there yesterday and it is a risk to your life. I have consigned a few things over the years since it opened. They have lost a custom ottoman I consigned. (She said she thought she gave to...
Noelle H.
1/30/2022
I've bought and consigned with them-buying is hit or miss, which is to be expected in a consignment shop. However, it's extremely un-organized to the point of almost being dangerous. It looks...
See a problem?
